Why we often sabotage relationships when things are going well

In my last blog, we explored why we sometimes find ourselves wanting people who don't want us back. We looked at the psychology of unavailability, the appeal of uncertainty in a nervous system sense, and how our early relationship experiences can influence who we're drawn to. 

Today, I want to take that conversation a step further and look at what happens when someone actually does want us back. When a relationship is healthy, someone is emotionally available, and things are going well, why do we often find ourselves wanting to burn it all to the ground?

For some people, emotional safety can feel unfamiliar. When we're accustomed to relationships characterized by inconsistency, uncertainty, or emotional unpredictability, a connection that offers stability can bring up feelings we don't quite know what to do with. 

And sometimes, rather than settling into that security, we find ways to fuck it up. Let’s talk about it.

Familiarity is a powerful beast.

Let’s recap a little from the last blog (which you should go read if you haven’t yet). As we discussed, our early experiences of relationships can shape what feels familiar to us in adulthood. If affection, attention, or emotional availability were inconsistent growing up, we may find ourselves gravitating towards dynamics that recreate that same feeling.

This doesn't mean we're consciously seeking out difficult relationships. Often, we're responding to learned patterns about what connection looks and feels like.

When someone is inconsistent, we might become preoccupied with securing their attention. When affection is unpredictable, we might work harder to maintain it. These dynamics can create a heightened emotional experience that we mistake for attraction or romantic compatibility.

By comparison, someone who communicates clearly, follows through on their promises, and offers consistent affection might initially feel less exciting to us. There's no emotional puzzle to solve, no constant reassurance to seek, and no uncertainty keeping us on high alert.

For someone accustomed to relational unpredictability, that absence of “the chase” can be difficult to interpret on an emotional level.

When your nervous system doesn't recognize safety.

Our nervous systems are constantly responding to cues of safety and threat, including within our relationships. If we've spent a long time navigating unsteady emotional environments, we can become attuned to signs of rejection, withdrawal, or conflict.

This can influence how we experience intimacy. A partner being emotionally available might trigger major fears around vulnerability, dependence, or anxiety about what could happen if we allow ourselves to become attached.

Sometimes, we interpret that discomfort as a sign that something is wrong with the relationship. We might suddenly question our attraction, become hypercritical of our partner, pick fights, or start looking for reasons to create distance.

Of course, not every doubt we have is self-sabotage, and discomfort shouldn't automatically be interpreted as evidence of an attachment issue. Sometimes relationships genuinely aren't right for us. But it's worth considering whether we're responding to something our partner is doing or to the vulnerability that comes with allowing someone to get close. Things to ponder, me thinks.

Creating distance before someone else beats you to it.

For some people, sabotaging a relationship can function as a form of self-protection. If intimacy means giving someone the opportunity to hurt us, ending things, withdrawing, or creating conflict can offer a temporary sense of control. And we love control. Even when it isn’t real.

We might convince ourselves that we're simply not interested anymore, become irritated by minor things, or emotionally withdraw just as the relationship starts to get more serious.

There's a psychological logic to this, actually. If we create the distance ourselves, we don't have to experience the uncertainty of waiting to see whether someone else will leave. We retain a sense of control over an emotionally vulnerable situation.

The problem is that these maladaptive protective strategies can also prevent us from experiencing the very connection we’re longing for with every fiber of our beings. Our little lovergirl hearts want love, but its fucking scary.

Learning to tolerate something different.

Recognizing these patterns takes time, and it requires a degree of honesty about the ways we participate in our own relationship dynamics. I know. You wanted easy solutions and here I am telling you, once again, it isn’t that simple.

But, here is where you can start.

When you notice yourself pulling away, becoming super critical, or questioning everything just as a relationship begins to feel secure, it can be helpful to pause before acting on those feelings.

Ask yourself what has actually changed. Has your partner done something that has made you feel unsafe or disconnected? Are there genuine incompatibilities or unmet needs? Or has the relationship simply reached a point where you're being asked to trust someone and allow yourself to be seen?

Learning to experience emotional safety can involve sitting with unfamiliar feelings rather than immediately trying to get to the bottom of them and find resolution. 

Therapy can also help us understand where these patterns originated and develop different ways of responding to intimacy.

Ultimately, healthy relationships still involve uncertainty, conflict, and moments of discomfort. Nobody can offer us complete emotional security, and no relationship should require us to ignore our needs or instincts.

But if we repeatedly find ourselves losing interest, creating conflict, or withdrawing whenever someone starts treating us well, it might be worth asking whether we're mistaking the absence of familiar chaos for a lack of attraction or compatibility.

Give it a think and notice what comes up for you. You’ve got this.

Next
Next

Why are we attracted to people who don’t want us back?